spacer
 HOME |  MY NEWT.ORG | AMERICAN SOLUTIONS | CHT | PARA LATINOS |
Grading the Big Speech

President Obama has had a month to listen to the American people.

For a month, angry Americans have gone to town hall meetings in large numbers to oppose more spending, more government, and more Washington centered bureaucracy.

For a month, the polls have gotten worse and worse for big spending, big deficit, high taxes, and big government.

But on Labor Day, President Obama gave us a sign he hasn't been listening. He gave a campaign-style speech in which he accused his critics of spreading "lies" and failing to offer their own solutions for health care reform.

Tonight President Obama has another opportunity to show us if he's willing to listen to us, or to his party's leftwing.

Below is a ten-point checklist you can use to judge for yourself.

Facing a Far Left Revolt, the President Has a Choice to Make

In his speech to Congress this evening, President Obama has a choice to make.

He has to choose between listening to what the American people are telling him, and what the Left is telling him.

A recent Gallup poll revealed that only 13% of the American people want permanently expanded government.

In sharp contrast, the liberal base of the President's party views government run health care as nonnegotiable.

The Left is already threatening primary opposition to President Obama if he doesn't stick with them and seek to impose radical change on the American people.

As MSNBC's Keith Olbermann said last week "If it's necessary to find somebody else to run against him, I think liberals would do it, no matter how destructive that may seem".

Despite the Hard Line of the Left, Health Care Reform Is Still Possible

Despite the intransigence on the Left, bipartisan health reform supported by a huge majority of Americans is still possible.

The question is whether the President can reach out to the majority of us.

So to understand the President's speech tonight -- his most important speech since his Inaugural address -- do these three things:

Forget the details.

Forget the rhetoric.

And ask yourself this:

Is this a speech designed to bring together Americans to pass bipartisan health reform?

Or is this a speech designed to appease the Left?

Here's a ten-point checklist to help you decide for yourself. Print it out and use it to judge the President's speech tonight.

  1. In his proposals for reform, does the President include litigation reform, which 84% of Americans believe will help reduce costs and which is the number one goal of doctors in any health reform?
  2. Does he include a section on saving money by stopping payments to crooks who are bilking the taxpayers for $70-120 billion each year in Medicare and Medicaid fraud? For 88 percent of Americans, this is the first place they would look to find savings in our health care system. Is President Obama willing to look there?
  3. Does his speech reject higher taxes, which the vast majority of Americans believe will make the current economy even worse and increase unemployment even more?
  4. Does it reject all government rationing of health services which the American people have vocally opposed at town hall meetings across the country?
  5. Does it reject any government run, bureaucratic health plan?
  6. Is President Obama open to four or five bipartisan bills which could pass with big bipartisan majorities? Or does he insist on a single omnibus bill of 1000-plus pages like the one that failed when Mrs. Clinton tried to pass it in 1993-1994?
  7. Is he for sustaining the Senate rule of 60 votes to ensure a bill that has wide, bipartisan support? Or is he prepared to destroy long-standing Senate tradition and ram through a radical bill with 51 votes?
  8. Does President Obama give any indication he is for increasing the power, information and choice of the individual and their doctor or is he giving more power to the government?
  9. Does he focus on health, wellness, prevention, early detection and health management to avoid or control the severity of chronic diseases? Or does he spend his time talking only about acute care?
  10. Does his plan invest in science and technology in order to increase innovation and accelerate the discovery and adoption of new discoveries and breakthroughs in diseases such as Alzheimer's, cancer and diabetes?
Share Your Scores With Me At HealthTransformation.net

When the speech is over, look over your check list.

Each "yes" is worth 10 percent.

Each failure is worth zero.

Share your score with me at healthtransformation.net.

And ask yourself this:

How close did the President come to a plan the American people actually want?

Your friend,
Newt Gingrich
Newt Gingrich

Newt's Quick Links :

  • My daughter, Jackie Cushman, offers her take on the President's speech to children yesterday. You can read it here
  • Also, make sure to take a sneak peek at our new bilingual opinion and news site geared towards Hispanics, The Americano.com. It highlights the rich history of Hispanic heritage and conservative principles while covering the issues most important to Hispanics today. Visit TheAmericano.com and share your thoughts before the official launch this month.


TagTag | Email Email | Print Print |
Comments
By Ed Tyler @ Friday, September 11, 2009 8:53 AM
If the President had wanted to make the most of his office, he should have taken the time to craft a speech that was clear, concise, actionable and understandable by the average American. Instead his speech was filled with text that requires a phrase by phrase deciphering to ascertain his true meaning.

It was apparent that Obama did this on purpose, as it allows each listener to develop their own interpretation of what was said. If one was inclined to agree, they could find a point of agreement.

Joe wilson had it perfectly correct. The President chose to communicate in a manner that obscures the true intent of his proposal. Some might call that great oratory, others would say that is was intentionally hiding the truth. Seems to me that is a great definition of a lie!
Ed

By apruett @ Thursday, September 10, 2009 3:40 PM
Did anyone notice that the President lowered his number of the uninsured from 47 million to 30 million tonight? And at the same time he said that the plan will not cover illegal immigrants. The explanation for the drop of the number from 47 to 30 million is because they are now, not counting illegal aliens. OK....but isn't a large part of the problem that the uninsured, including illegals, show up at emergency rooms and get treatment, without paying for it, which we all pay for with increased premiums and taxes? Well, according to Obama's own number, there will be approximately 17 million illegals out there, that will not be covered by Obamacare, that will still be doing the same thing! And if illegal immigration is not ended, does anyone think this number will do anything but grow? It will continue, and Obamacare will not be able to contain any kind of costs at all. If I believed everything he said tonight (and I don't), this is a gaping hole in his plan that there is no political will to fix. So why should we add to the deficit for a solution that really doesn't solve anything?

By Wa_Cowboy @ Thursday, September 10, 2009 2:24 PM
Guys,
You don't pay for a project by elimanating fraud and abuse from another. Medicare needs that money, take it from the crooks, fine them and let Medicare have it all. It really does need it. Tort reform, no refusal on preexisting, no cancelling b/c you are sick, no life time limits on coverage, no Federal government control, and let the states control insurance competition, (protect "State's Rights"). These are "Health Care Reforms".

The speech, with its "finger pointing" was not appropriate. As much as I agree with congressman who shouted "You're Lying", it was inappropriate it that setting. That setting is or should be the most respected venue in our government.

By fmdavis1943 @ Thursday, September 10, 2009 2:03 PM
I applaud Rep Joe Wilson for calling it the way he see it,,, finally a congressman stands up to the president and calls him a liar that he is ,,, we need more Republicans to do the same,,, when the President or other members of congress lie then call them out publicly on it and stop apologizing for it, they sure do call us on it,,,, we the people haven’t got the opportunity to call the president on his lies but congress does and should,,,, well done Congressman Wilson, you earned my vote

By RB46 @ Thursday, September 10, 2009 12:20 AM
What a shame, according to President Obama, most of the public Option can be paid by reducing waste in Medicare & Medicaid. You mean that Congress has known that there is a waste of about $64 Billions and has done nothing throughout the years to correct the problem? In a private company those Lawmakers would be without job!!!

By nancy512 @ Thursday, September 10, 2009 12:18 AM
He certainly did not bring Americans together. He was appeasing the Left while trying not to look like it.
Still pushing the public option but attempted to gloss over and downplay it like a small inconsequential point ... "a means to an end." Yes We Can. He's trying to get us to let down our guard. No mention of how to pay for it or higher taxes. No basis in reality whatsoever.

The shameless Kennedy plug turned into a puke inducing Ode To Government. I think Biden wiped a tear.

He threw us a Tort Reform cookie. Thanks.

By PeakView @ Wednesday, September 09, 2009 11:08 PM
Obama makes up a lie; he repeats the lie; he repeats the lie; and he repeats the lie. Eventually, when he tells the lie enough, people begin to believe him. We just have to be vigilant of the lies, and call him and his cronies to an accounting. Stay vigilant!

By jawjahfay @ Wednesday, September 09, 2009 10:51 PM
The president spoke tonight as if he has heard nothing from the American people.He made snide remarks about Republican conflict but it seems his decline in the polls has had no effect on him.He spoke to the ears of the left, for the most part he said what he knew they wanted to hear.I was a tiny bit surprised he brought up abortion and declared that it would not be government funded, though I don't believe that for one second.He filled in the same points with a lot of TALK, just the 'same old same old'.He made the statement that American physicians were for the government plan yet nothing about the appeal of over 10,000 physicians who request they have input into healthcare reform.Obama just could not pass up a speech without blaming the past administration.The atmosphere surrounding Obama was staged.It's been rehearsed so many times, like I said, the 'same old same old rerun.' I have zero confidence in the current bunch of 'groupies' in the White House.They give the appearance of being on a perpetual fraternity party binge.What is most terrifying is that they got this far.

By dbowman @ Wednesday, September 09, 2009 9:33 PM
Just as Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid were started without any real awareness of their long-term costs, nationalized healthcare will just pile more unfunded liabilities on top of an already hopelessly out of balance cost picture. The president appears to be appealing to emotion rather than reason. Of course we want everyone to have health care. The only question is how in the world can it be paid for when we can't fund the entitlements we already have?

By mymediumrare @ Wednesday, September 09, 2009 9:26 PM
I wonder what type of mind-altering substance President Obama has to be using in order to conclude that a "strong majority" of americans want a public option in the healthcare bill. The polls clearly show the majority do not want the public option.

His drive to replace our Constitutional Republic and capitalism with a socialist state and economy is absolutely the scariest thing I've ever encountered.

Click Here to post a comment

About Newt

Contact

Internships

FAQ's

Terms of Use

 
Powered By: Powered By iBelong Networks
spacer